Substack vs Ghost vs Beehiiv: fees at 500, 5,000 and 50,000 subscribers
The cheapest newsletter platform at 500 subscribers is rarely the cheapest at 50,000. The pricing models pull in different directions as you grow, so the right pick depends on where you are headed, not just where you are now.
How the three charge
Substack takes a percentage of paid subscriptions and nothing for a free list, which is gentle to start and costly once you have real paid revenue. Ghost charges a flat tier by subscriber count whether they pay you or not. Beehiiv sits between, with tiers plus some revenue tools. So a free list of 50,000 is cheap on Substack and dear on Ghost, while a large paid list flips the maths entirely.
The rough shape
At 500 free subscribers all three are close to free. At 5,000 you start paying Ghost and Beehiiv a monthly tier. At 50,000 paid on Substack, the percentage cut can dwarf a flat Ghost fee. There is no winner here, only a cheapest-for-your-numbers, so run your own list size and paid share through each before you commit, because moving later is a genuine pain.
Prices change often, so check each provider directly rather than trusting a comparison from last year.
Written by Kate Lindqvist. General information for creators, not financial advice; figures current for 2026.
